New Episodes Every Thursday
Cold and Missing

Cold and Missing

Cold and Missing focuses exclusively on cold cases and unsolved missing person cases. Every week Ali and Eli - a husband and wife duo- will bring you either a Cold Case or a unresolved missing person. Ethically, we are not interested in talking about solved cases and reliving another families trauma. We are interested in being a small part of the solution and the hope of the podcast is to keep unsolved cases in peoples mind and generate tips. Cold and Missing is for fans of true crime who appreciate deep research into cases.

The player is loading ...
Cold and Missing

Recent Episodes

Feb. 20, 2025

Cold and Missing: Annie McCarrick

In March 1993, 27-year-old Annie McCarrick vanished from Dublin, Ireland, leaving behind a mystery that remains unsolved over 30 years later. Originally from New York, she had embraced life in Ireland, but on the day she dis…
Feb. 13, 2025

Cold and Missing: Heidi Seeman

In August 1990, 11-year-old Heidi Seeman disappeared while walking home in San Antonio, Texas. A red car with tinted windows had been seen circling her before she vanished. Despite massive searches and multiple reported sigh…
Jan. 30, 2025

Cold and Missing: James ‘Amp’ Reynolds

Six friends set out for a night of fun in Opp, Alabama, in May 1999, but they never made it home. James “Amp” Reynolds and his friends were last seen leaving the Hideaway Club around 3:15 AM, piling into a newly souped-up Ch…
Jan. 23, 2025

Cold and Missing: Hannah Truelove

In August 2012, 16-year-old Hannah Truelove was a bright, animal-loving junior at Gainesville High School with dreams of becoming a veterinarian. Living with her mom in the Lake Lanier Club Apartments, she was well-loved for…
Jan. 16, 2025

Cold and Missing: Tavish Sutton

In this gripping episode, we delve into the mysterious disappearance of one-month-old Tavish Sutton, who was abducted from his hospital room at Grady Memorial in Atlanta, Georgia, on March 9, 1993. Born to a mother strugglin…
Jan. 9, 2025

Cold and Missing: Joyner Ondimu

Episode Summary: In this episode, we delve into the tragic and mysterious case of Joyner Ondimu, a 23-year-old Kenyan nursing student living in Newark, Delaware. Known for her big heart, culinary talent, and dedication to he…

Recent Blog Posts

May 29, 2023

Trail Scent for Brandon Swanson

This is from Episode 41 about the missing person case of Brandon Swanson. The scent dogs were brought in the second day of the search from Codington, County South Dakota. From Brandon’s vehicle, it traveled ½ mile south then turned …

Read the Blog Post

About the Hosts

Eli Sulkowski Profile Photo

Eli Sulkowski

Co-Host

Eli Sulkowski is a multifaceted artist. He’s an actor, painter, woodworker, writer, podcast host, and dancer. He earned his BA in Theatre from Aquinas College in Grand Rapids, MI. Originally hailing from Detroit, Michigan- Eli moved to Chicago to pursue a more diverse career in a bigger city. Since moving to Chicago, Eli has signed with Gray Talent Group and has primarily focused on his acting career. His TV debut was season 1 of SHOWTIME’s Work In Progress. Modeling credits include: Google Pixel, Eyebobs, and Sandro Miller. Theatre credits include: Victory Gardens Theatre, Broken Nose Theatre, and Pride Films & Plays. He is the co-host and graphic designer for the podcast Cold & Missing- produced and hosted by his wife, Ali McLaughlin Sulkowski. Eli also owns and operates an upcycled furniture and homegoods company- Moo Furniture Company. He is a freelance script editing consultant, actor coach, and graphic designer. Eli's most recent editing and graphic design work is in pre-production with the short film Order For Ben with fellow trans filmmaker Adam Plant.

Ali McLaughlin-Sulkowski Profile Photo

Ali McLaughlin-Sulkowski

Creator & Host

Ali is the creator of Cold and Missing. Growing up the passion for true crime was planted early by spending countless hours watching tv shows with her mother. As she grew up and the world of podcasting exploded she knew she wanted to create a podcast with her passion for true crime. However, ethically speaking she did not want to cause another family trauma by bringing up their worst day. Instead she wanted to be a small part of the solution and her love of the unsolved seemed obvious. By focusing on cold cases and unresolved missing person cases Ali hopes to help keep the name of the victims alive and let the families know that their loved one is not forgotten about. Thanks for stopping by and stay safe y’all!