New Episodes Every Thursday

Cold Case Episodes

Oct. 30, 2023

Cold and Missing: Sigrid Stevenson

Sigrid Stevenson, a 25-year-old graduate student at Trenton State College in New Jersey, was found brutally beaten to death on September 4, 1977. She had returned to campus after hitchhiking through Canada and New England and...

Listen to the Episode
Oct. 16, 2023

Cold and Missing: Stella Bolton & JJ Moore

Stella and JJ were roommates and close friends who lived in a working-class neighborhood in Portsmouth, New Hampshire. Stella was known for her kindness and generosity towards her neighbors, while JJ was a veteran with a love...

Listen to the Episode
Sept. 18, 2023

Cold and Missing: Silene ‘Erica’ Eaddy

An early morning driver notices a brush fire in a wooded area in the outskirts of Colombia, S.C and calls for help. As firefighters respond to the call and get to work extinguishing the blaze they make the gruesome discovery ...

Listen to the Episode
Sept. 6, 2023

Cold and Missing: Larry Jo Phebus

In 1962, fourteen year-old Larry Jo Phebus was new in North Dakota when he found himself alone on a Saturday night. His brother, who he lived with, had a double date and Larry Jo was told to stay at their hotel. When his brot...

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 21, 2023

Cold and Missing: Charles and Jennifer Chia

The space between the bus stop and Charles and Jennifer Chia’s apartment is 100 feet. Somewhere in that 100 feet Charles and Jennifer vanish without a trace in the middle of the day on October 18th, 1989. Quickly, everyone in...

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 7, 2023

Cold and Missing: Sister Roberta ‘Robin’ Elam

Postulant nun Sister Robin Elam (full name: Roberta Elam) was spending time at her convent for an 8 day silent retreat. Her time was spent praying and meditating and those that knew her assumed she was also using the time to wrestle with her decision to take her vows. On June 13th, 1977 Sister Robi…

Listen to the Episode
July 24, 2023

Cold and Missing: Chance Smith

Chance Smith was a recent ‘Student of the Week’ for his kindergarten class and said one of his favorite things was playing outside. In December of 2003 Chance was doing just that, playing outside, while his grandfather worked on an engine nearby. His grandfather stepped inside for a minute to grab …

Listen to the Episode
July 3, 2023

Cold and Missing: Sarah Greenhalgh

Sarah Greenhalgh updated her facebook status at 11:00 pm on July 8th, 2012. It said “Going to be sleeping with the window wide open…:-) Now if batsh** crazy-boy would just leave me alone…will get some much needed rest because tomorrow is Monday and I got a ton of work to do”. The next morning, just…

Listen to the Episode
June 19, 2023

Cold and Missing: Luther Meshell

In March of 1991 Luther Meshell, who used a wheelchair and crutches in his day to day, was found brutally murdered in his home. He had been stabbed in his back, chest, and had his throat cut. Several items were taken from the home- most notably his 1977 Oldsmobile Delta 88. However, the next day po…

Listen to the Episode
June 5, 2023

Cold and Missing: Earl and Clarissa Gonzales

Earl and Clarissa Gonzales were a father daughter duo well known in their small town of Questa, New Mexico. The entire town was shocked when Earl and Clarissa were both found murdered on September 2nd, 1999. Earl had been shot in the head while he slept and Clarissa died from a ligature strangulati…

Listen to the Episode
May 22, 2023

Cold and Missing: Aaron Dowdle

In the early morning hours of April 1, 2005 fifteen year old Aaron Dowdle was found behind a vacant warehouse beaten into a coma and stabbed. A few hours earlier Aaron’s best friend had been found in the same condition a few hours earlier and just blocks away. Both boys are rushed to the hospital a…

Listen to the Episode
May 8, 2023

Cold and Missing: Kenneth Charlot

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli look into the 2018 cold case of Kenneth Charlot. Kenneth was proud of his family and his home in Pass Christian, Mississippi reflected the love he had for all his nieces and nephews. When family couldn’t get ahold of Kenneth on Feb 1st, 2018 they knew somet…

Listen to the Episode
April 24, 2023

Cold and Missing: Shirley McAvoy

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli to look into the 1990 cold case of Shirley McAvoy. In August of 1990 Shirley was living in Pittsfield, Maine when she disappeared. Family and friends thought that she was taking some time to herself to process her recent separation from her husband. When fa…

Listen to the Episode
April 10, 2023

Cold and Missing: April Marie Sanchez

This week on Cold and Missing we look into the 2003 cold case of April Marie Sanchez in San Jose, CA. April was a vivacious 16 year old who was spending time with friends and her boyfriend late Friday night. When she left a little after midnight to walk home it should have taken her 25 minutes but …

Listen to the Episode
March 28, 2023

Cold and Missing: Baby Victor

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli look into the 1986 cold case out of Fairfield, CT of an infant known as Baby Victor. Hours after being born baby Victor is found dead near Lake Mohegan. Three conservation workers were emptying trash cans when they found a newborn lying on the ground and wr…

Listen to the Episode