Cold Case Episodes

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli look into the 1973 cold case of Sherri Swalley. Sherri was 8 years old when her father decided to take her and her little brother to Walt Disney World as a Christmas treat. Traveling from Columbus, OH to Orlando, FL Sherri’s father decided to spend Sunday D…

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli look into the chilling cold case of Keisha Murray. In July of 2013 in Jacksonville, Fl Keisha’s body was found sitting under a tree in the Restlawn Cemetery. Police quickly conclude that it is a homicide and reveal that Keisha was bathed and dressed after h…

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli look into the 2011 cold case of Jeremey Toles out of Midwest City, Oklahoma. In 2011 Jeremy had the world in front of him. He was a customer favorite at his job, had found a passion for cooking, and had just become a proud father. However, after an evening …

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli take a look at a 1988 cold case out of San Antonio, Texas. Eight year old Jennifer Delgado and her mother were doing laundry at a laundromat located across the street from their home. A man entered the laundromat and tried to use the soda vending machine. W…

This week Ali and Eli cover the cold case of Jubilee ‘Maile’ Lum from August of 1999. This cold case takes us to the island of O’ahu. Maile was last seen getting into a late 80s or early 90s Econoline van on a Monday morning. The next day by noon her body was disposed of behind a flower shop. Three…

Ali and Eli are back in the new year with a brand new cold case. This week we talk about the unsolved murder of Lesley Sparrow who’s murdered body was found October 14th, 1979 in the trunk of her own car. Lesley had been invited to a sky diving competition that weekend in Arizona but never made it …

This week on Cold and Missing we get to bring you updates on cases that we have covered in 2022. First up the recent arrest of Gene Meyer for the 1988 under and assault of Betty Rolf (episode 15) in Appleton, WI. We discuss the modern investigation of DNA in this case along with the family’s reacti…

Betty Rolf found herself in the middle of the first Wisconsin snowstorm in the winter of November 1988. Betty, who hated driving in the snow, decided to walk to work. The walk should have taken no time since it was about half a mile and on the same street as her home. Betty never makes it to work h…

In 2021, seventeen year old Johnkelian ‘John John’ Mathis had just gotten off of work and was headed to an annual neighborhood homecoming. After the celebration crowds remained to continue to enjoy each other’s company. Shortly after 1am shots rang out and three people had been struck by the gunfir…

BONUS EPISODE; recent developments in the Abby Williams and Libby German case. A man named Richard Allen has been charged with two counts of murder. Listen to the episode as we go over the most recent press conference given 10/31/2022. We also review past press conferences to bring the most accurat…

This week Ali and Eli cover a cold case out of Etters, PA. Kimberly Yohe was 20 years old when she was last seen at her family home. Two weeks later Kimberly’s body would be found by fisherman with her arms bound behind her back. An investigation would determine that her cause of death was strangul…

This week on Cold and Missing we cover the case of Abigail ‘Abby’ Williams and Liberty ‘libby’ German who were murdered February 13th, 2017 in a small town of Delphi, Indiana while enjoying a day off from school and walking on a popular nature trail. Ali is solo in hosting this week as Eli is shoot…

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli dive into the cold case of family man John Leonard, Sr. In 1970 John was working as a taxi driver when he received a request for a short ride. John would be found dead in his cab due to 4 gunshot wounds at The Inn at Buck Hill Falls. No suspects are ever an…

On December 5th, 2001, 70 year old Margie Dabney was traveling from Indianapolis, IN to their home is Bakersfield, CA. During their flight they were going to have a short layover at the Dallas/For Worth airport to switch planes. Somewhere between gate 35 and gate 39 Margie Dabney disappeared. To fu…

On April 17th, 1983 high school senior Corinne Perry heads to a local laundromat on a Sunday evening. A man follows her as she leaves the laundromat and she is never heard from again. November 3rd, 1984 after missing for over a year and half her bones are found by hunters. Join us this week as we d…